“You are a department manager in a mid-sized company that provides technology support services. You have ten employees who are required to maintain a high level of technical expertise and deliver excellent customer service. One of your employees, who has been with the company for two years, is performing at a substandard level and you have received numerous complaints from customers and coworkers. In addition, this employee has displayed confrontational behavior which has created a hostile environment. You must now meet with this employee and deliver an ultimatum regarding the need for immediate improvement or dismissal.”
Before confronting this employee, I would do my due diligence and assemble records of her productivity logs. I would also collect records of complaints lodged against her. Lastly, I would review her personnel file to get a sense of trends in her communication and performance. This would all be done in a fast manner as when delivering bad news, you do not want to wait. Waiting too long could cause further harm. The employee could garner more negative attention and complaints from co-workers and clientele if left unchecked. The goal is not to frighten the employee into submission, but rather to keep the peace and improve output. “If you must deliver bad news to an employee, your primary goal is to maintain goodwill and trust” (Guffey p. 217).
Being prepared will yield better results, especially when confronting someone about their work performance. Technical Communication – tenth edition supports this by saying, “Do your homework. Be prepared to support each assertion, conclusion, opinion and recommendation with evidence and reason” (Lannon p. 658). I'd first create a checklist of items I would need to support my case. It would also be beneficial to discretely approach other supervisors about her history with the organization. On the checklist, I would also include points that I want to cover with the employee. These points could help uncover invaluable information that could help the employee advocate for herself.
I would ask how she is feeling in general and follow that up by asking how she feels about her job with our department. These questions could give the employee a needed avenue for venting – potentially explaining her sub-par performance on the job. As she spoke, I would listen actively to gain her confidence and make her comfortable sharing. I would speak in a calm, soft tone that was clear and professional while maintaining good eye contact.
Now, it is time to get direct. “Listeners’ normal attention span is only about twenty minutes” (Lannon p. 658). After easing into it, I would produce my folder containing documentation of her declining performance. I would calmly tell her that I am concerned about her work. I would expect her to respond with surprise and perhaps ask for clarification. In response, I would tell her that I am concerned that I have received a number of complaints that her work is not up to par. Next, I would give specific examples and even allow her to read any information that she should be privileged to read. I would ask for her thoughts on what I have said and on what she has read.
The next documentation that I would present would be a list of the trainings that this employee has taken. I would remind her of the things that she should be retaining and practicing from those trainings and ask if she felt she would perform better with a refresher course. I would mention that this may empower her and boost her confidence in her work. Following this up, I would offer her some more trainings that could help shore up her inefficiencies.
The last thing I would do I document the meeting with my signature and hers. We would also document the fact that she was presented with an opportunity to improve on her own accord and will attend a certain number of trainings. A follow-up date would be set for when she and I could meet and assess her trainings and performance. Before ending this portion of the meeting, I would ask if she has any lingering questions or concerns and address them respectively.
That covers the performance part. Now I would mention to her that she is being thought to have created a hostile work environment and the far reaching impacts that can have on her, other employees, management and the organization. I would explain in detail what the complaints said and of course, produce documentation that was allowed and ask for her thoughts and clarification in the matter. I anticipate her need for training and mastery of her job being the root of her hostility, so I will give her a chance to tell me if the trainings and follow-up coaching will help her in this area.
I would document that she and I met regarding the matter. She and I would also discuss ways of dealing with situation which cause people to feel hostility from her. She would then be presented with an open ended question about what she is going to do to change her image and the climate in the office that has been described as hostile.